After more than nine consecutive years of steady growth, proposal activity in the U.S. Multifamily Housing market flattened in the 1st Quarter amid the COVID-19 crisis. The Quarterly Market Forecast (QMF) survey of architecture, engineering and construction (A/E/C) firms reported the first negative result for Multifamily since the 3rd Quarter of 2010.
Multifamily has consistently been one of the strongest performers among 58 submarkets measured in PSMJ Resources’ quarterly survey. This includes the 4th Quarter of 2019 when Multifamily’s Net Plus/Minus Index (NPMI) of 54% was the highest among all submarkets. Its NPMI slid to -2% in the 1st Quarter of 2020, as the percentage of respondents reporting a quarter-to-quarter decrease in proposal activity climbed from 4% to 31%.
PSMJ’s NPMI expresses the difference between the percentage of firms reporting an increase in proposal activity and those reporting a decrease over the three-month period. A consistent group of over 300 A/E/C firm leaders participate regularly, with 288 contributing to the most recent survey. It was conducted from March 24-30.
Despite the drop into the negative, Multifamily held up far better than three other Housing submarkets – Single-Family Properties (-31%), Single-Family Developments (-28%) and Condominiums (-28%) were among the 12 poorest-performing submarkets in the 1st Quarter.
Prior to this crisis, the consensus among industry economists and experts was that Multifamily would stay strong in 2020, albeit with some challenges to face. National vacancy rates were creeping up and much of the supply deficit had been filled. Nonetheless, significant amounts of investment money remained available and demand persisted in varying levels regionally. The fact that Multifamily proposal activity wasn’t as negatively impacted in the 1st Quarter as other Housing submarkets were, even with the COVID-19 crisis beginning to affect the market in March, suggests that it could recover comparatively quickly and seamlessly when and where restrictions are eased.
PSMJ Senior Principal David Burstein, P.E., AECPM, said he expects all housing markets to rebound after the health crisis passes and the record-low interest rates endure. “Pent up demand should make its presence felt by the end of the 3rd Quarter, and even more so in the 4th Quarter, especially if we see movement on an infrastructure bill.”
Multifamily’s performance in the QMF reinforces how consistently lucrative the sector has been for nearly a decade. After recording an NPMI of -5% in the 3rd Quarter of 2010, the Multifamily submarket experienced four consecutive quarters with a respectable NPMI between 20% and 26%. It jumped to a healthy 44% in the 4th Quarter of 2012 and remained at or above 42% for the next 28 quarters, all the way through 2019.
For the 4th Quarter of 2019, 58% of respondents said that proposal opportunities had increased in the Multifamily market, with only 4% reporting a decrease. For the 1st Quarter of 2020, increases were halved to 29%, compared with 31% that saw a drop in proposal activity.
Consulting and publishing firm PSMJ Resources, Inc., has been conducting the QMF survey each quarter since 2003. You can find more information at https://www.psmj.com/surveys/quarterly-market-forecast-2.
Related Stories
MFPRO+ New Projects | Oct 30, 2024
BIG’s One High Line finally reaches completion in New York City’s West Chelsea neighborhood
One High Line, a luxury residential project spanning a full city block in New York’s West Chelsea neighborhood, reached completion this summer following years of delays related to investor lawsuits.
MFPRO+ New Projects | Oct 30, 2024
Luxury waterfront tower in Brooklyn features East River and Manhattan skyline views
Leasing recently began for The Dupont, a 41-story luxury rental property along the Brooklyn, N.Y., waterfront. Located within the 22-acre Greenpoint Landing, where it overlooks the newly constructed Newtown Barge Park, the high-rise features East River and Manhattan skyline views along with 20,000 sf of indoor and outdoor communal space.
Multifamily Housing | Oct 28, 2024
A case for mid-rise: How multifamily housing can reshape our cities
Often referred to as “five-over-ones,” the mid-rise apartment type is typically comprised of five stories of apartments on top of a concrete “podium” of ground-floor retail. The main criticism of the “five-over-one” is that they are often too predictable.
Adaptive Reuse | Oct 22, 2024
Adaptive reuse project transforms 1840s-era mill building into rental housing
A recently opened multifamily property in Lawrence, Mass., is an adaptive reuse of an 1840s-era mill building. Stone Mill Lofts is one of the first all-electric mixed-income multifamily properties in Massachusetts. The all-electric building meets ambitious modern energy codes and stringent National Park Service historic preservation guidelines.
MFPRO+ News | Oct 22, 2024
Project financing tempers robust demand for multifamily housing
AEC Giants with multifamily practices report that the sector has been struggling over the past year, despite the high demand for housing, especially affordable products.
Products and Materials | Oct 17, 2024
5 multifamily tech products for your next project
Multifamily housing and technological upgrades go hand-in-hand. From the rise in electric vehicle charging needs to the sophistication of smart home accessories, tech products are abound in the multifamily space.
Codes and Standards | Oct 16, 2024
North Carolina’s code policies likely worsened damage caused by Hurricane Helene
The North Carolina Legislature’s rejection of building code updates likely worsened the damage caused by Hurricane Helene, code experts say. Over the past 15 years, lawmakers rejected limits on construction on steep slopes, which might have reduced the number of homes destroyed by landslides.
MFPRO+ News | Oct 16, 2024
One-third of young adults say hurricanes like Helene and Milton will impact where they choose to live
Nearly one-third of U.S. residents between 18 and 34 years old say they are reconsidering where they want to move after seeing the damage wrought by Hurricane Helene, according to a Redfin report. About 15% of those over age 35 echoed their younger cohort’s sentiment.
Student Housing | Oct 9, 2024
University of Maryland begins work on $148 million graduate student housing development
The University of Maryland, in partnership with Campus Apartments and Mosaic Development Partners, has broken ground on a $148.75 million graduate student housing project on the university’s flagship College Park campus. The project will add 741 beds in 465 fully furnished apartments.
MFPRO+ News | Oct 9, 2024
San Francisco unveils guidelines to streamline office-to-residential conversions
The San Francisco Department of Building Inspection announced a series of new building code guidelines clarifying adaptive reuse code provisions and exceptions for converting office-to-residential buildings. Developed in response to the Commercial to Residential Adaptive Reuse program established in July 2023, the guidelines aim to increase the viability of converting underutilized office buildings into housing by reducing regulatory barriers in specific zoning districts downtown.
