flexiblefullpage
billboard
interstitial1
catfish1
Currently Reading

New survey exposes achievement gap between men and women designers

Industry Research

New survey exposes achievement gap between men and women designers

Female architects still feel disadvantaged when it comes to career advancement. 


By John Caulfield, Senior Editor | November 4, 2016

A survey of more than 8,600 architects reveals a perception gap between men and women about their career development and advancement opportunities. Image: Pixabay

A new “Equity in Architecture” survey finds that women and people of color continue to lag white men at architecture firms in career success measures such are salaries and advancement. This “achievement gap,” according to this survey, is less the result of systemic racism or sexism (although both still play in the background, like elevator music, at many firms), and more due to the lack of transparency in a firm’s process of promotions, equal access to its senior leaders, ongoing performance feedback, and having meaningful relationships at work.

The survey, conducted by the Equity by Design committee of AIA San Francisco, is based on responses to more than 80 questions from 8,664 graduates of architecture schools who are either working for an architecture firm, have worked for a firm but currently are employed in another profession, or have worked for a firm but are taking a career break or leave of absence.

The vast majority of respondents, nearly 7,000, are white males or females. And 6,600 respondents currently work at an architecture firm.

Nearly 80% of respondents said they shared their companies’ values, and 60% are engaged in decision-making and “find my work meaningful.” However, a deeper dive into the responses finds that in virtually every metric of success—including autonomy, compensation, confidence, meaningful work, focus, and work-life balance—men are more positive about their situations than women are.

 

The survey finds that female architects who are encouraged by a firm's senior leaders are more likely to stay with that job, and feel better about it, than men archtects. Image: Atelier Cho Thompson, courtesy of AIA San Francisco Equity in Design Committee.

 

One reasons might be that men are better prepared than women to take on new roles, based on their perceived respective access to a firm’s partner, principal or direct manager for professional guidance. Mentoring is critical to retention, and when women receive guidance from one of their firm’s senior leaders, they are more likely than men to stay at their jobs, be energized by their work, and be optimistic about their careers. Career guidance also has a positive effect on women architects’ attitudes about work-life balance and “focus.”

One-fifth of the survey’s respondents said that the top reason why they left their last job was low pay. And the survey finds ongoing disparities in the salaries being paid men versus women. For example, the average salary for male respondents with eight to 10 years’ experience was around $75,000, versus around $70,000 for women with the same tenure. The salary gap between men and women widens with experience. And a woman architect who is a parent, regardless of experience, is likely to be paid less than childless women, or men with or without children.

Annelise Pitts, a designer with Bohlin Cywinski Jackson and research chairman of Equity by Design, notes that women—who account for two-fifths of architecture school graduates—early in their careers often get shuttled into less-than-edifying tasks like office manager or office librarian. This “gender sorting,” says Pitts, gives women less of a shot at eventually being included in the firm’s strategic management decisions.

Once an architect has been with a firm for more than a decade, there is a significant jump in his or her perception about the likelihood of becoming a principal in their firm. However, more than half of all respondents said their firms’ leadership is “mostly male.” And 27% of male respondents and 32% of female respondents said their companies’ promotion process is either somewhat or very ineffective. Non-white males are the least likely employees to be made principals, the survey showed.

(While the survey only touches on workplace diversity, Pitts says that the biggest issue for the architectural industry remains “getting people of color into the pipeline in the first place.” Research also finds that even when minority employees are hired, they are more likely to leave firms sooner than white men or women.)

More than three-fifths of the respondents said they have “scheduling conflicts” that present challenges to maintaining a work-life balance. And women more than men attribute poor health, neglected duties, and relationship conflicts in their personal lived to this imbalance. “Women seem more willing to compromise their personal lives for work,” says Pitts. However, women are also more likely than men to turn down work-related travel because of conflicts with their personal lives.

 

Women architects are more likely than men to sacrifice their personal lives for work, but are also more likely to feel the pressures of the job. Image: Atelier Cho Thompson, courtesy AIA San Francisco Equity in Design committee.

 

Burnout is more prevalent among women, especially those with less than five years experience. Half of the female respondents with five or fewer years on the job left their firm, compared to 42% of men with that same tenure who exited. Interestingly, more-tenured women appear to be less likely to leave their firms than experienced men.

Among the respondents, 667 men and 719 women currently work outside of an architecture practice. The vast majority works in another field, with a relatively small number—less than 10%—either being a full-time caregiver, a student, unemployed, or retired.

The solution to hiring and retention problems at architecture firms the survey exposes, says Pitts, comes down to them having policies in place that emphasize progressive and fair employee development, and enforcing those policies equitably and transparently. “Companies need to walk the walk,” she says.

Related Stories

Industry Research | Feb 8, 2016

Changing of the guard: Big cities giving way to newer, less expensive offerings

U-Haul truck rental costs are a good early predictor of migration trends in the U.S.

Multifamily Housing | Feb 2, 2016

10 top bathroom design trends for 2016

Floating vanities, tricked-out showers, and freestanding tubs highlight the top bathroom design trends, according to a survey of kitchen and bath design professionals by the National Kitchen and Bath Association.

Multifamily Housing | Feb 1, 2016

Top 10 kitchen design trends for 2016

Charging stations, built-in coffeemakers, and pet stations—these are among the top kitchen design trends for the coming year, according to a new survey of kitchen and bath designers by the National Kitchen & Bath Association.

Market Data | Jan 20, 2016

Architecture Billings Index ends year on positive note

While volatility persists, architecture firms reported healthy performance for 2015.

Industry Research | Dec 23, 2015

Meet the world’s next great construction superpower

There’s a new world construction hotbed coming down the pike (more specifically, the Mumbai Nashik Expressway), and it could mean a major boon for AEC firms.

Industry Research | Dec 21, 2015

Experts predict commercial real estate trends for 2016

Midwest Experts Predict Commercial Real Estate Trends for 2016, according to  real estate communications firm TaylorJohnson.

Industry Research | Dec 17, 2015

The 2016 commercial construction market: A contractor’s view

The CFO of Tocci Building Companies forecasts the outlook for commercial and institutional construction in 2016.

Office Buildings | Dec 9, 2015

HOK collaborates with IFMA on new workplace strategy research report

Report cites work-life balance as the top reason for implementing “distributed work” strategies.

Industry Research | Dec 8, 2015

AEC leaders say the 'talent wars' are heating up: BD+C exclusive survey

A new survey from Building Design+Construction shows that U.S. architecture, engineering, and construction firms are being stymied by the shortage of experienced design and construction professionals and project managers.

Market Data | Dec 7, 2015

2016 forecast: Continued growth expected for the construction industry

ABC forecasts growth in nonresidential construction spending of 7.4% in 2016 along with growth in employment and backlog.

boombox1
boombox2
native1

More In Category




Contractors

Conflict resolution is a critical skill for contractors

Contractors interact with other companies seventeen times a day on average, and nearly half of those interactions (eight) involve conflicts, according to a report by Dodge Construction Network and Dusty Robotics. The study suggests that specialty trade contractors, in particular, rarely experience good resolution from conflicts. 

halfpage1

Most Popular Content

  1. 2021 Giants 400 Report
  2. Top 150 Architecture Firms for 2019
  3. 13 projects that represent the future of affordable housing
  4. Sagrada Familia completion date pushed back due to coronavirus
  5. Top 160 Architecture Firms 2021