The Federal Emergency Management Agency recently sent a letter to officials in Lee County, Florida alleging that hundreds of homes were rebuilt in violation of the agency’s rules following Hurricane Ian. The letter provoked a sharp backlash as homeowners struggle to rebuild following the devastating 2022 storm that destroyed a large swath of the county.
The controversy stems from how subsidized flood insurance from FEMA is administered. FEMA insurance comes with the stipulation that if a home in a flood zone suffers damages worth more than half of its value, it must be torn down and rebuilt so it’s elevated above flood level. This is an expensive proposition for homeowners, but it is intended to prevent U.S. taxpayers from paying for repeated destruction of homes in vulnerable locations.
It is up to local officials in damaged zones to enforce this rule, which is a condition for FEMA to provide discounted flood insurance to homeowners. FEMA’s letter to Lee County threatened to revoke the insurance discount, alleging that the county was lax in enforcing the rebuilding rule.
County officials received angry complaints from constituents and considered suing the agency in a heated meeting. In the aftermath, FEMA gave the county an extra 30 days to make the case that it hadn’t allowed homeowners to rebuild in violation of its rules.
FEMA’s letter indicates a change in the federal government’s mindset in that it is now prepared to crack down on continued risky construction in floodplains. How this situation plays out in Lee County will be watched closely by officials in other coastal areas vulnerable to storm damage and flooding. It may be a harbinger of how FEMA will address rebuilding efforts in the future.
Related Stories
Resiliency | Jul 27, 2016
New York’s resilience plans not taking long-term view, critics charge
Continued waterfront development may be regretted later this century.
Resiliency | Jul 18, 2016
Impact fees on development proposed to fund Miami’s rising sea level resiliency plans
$400 million flood plan includes new valves, pumps, and raised roadways.
Resiliency | Jun 1, 2016
Federal agencies boost standards for more resilient construction
HUD, FEMA, GSA, Army Corps of Engineers make policy changes.
Green | May 31, 2016
Miami Beach requires developers to meet green standards or pay a fee
Applies to structures larger than 7,000 sf.
Resiliency | May 12, 2016
Resilience Building Coalition releases progress report
The coalition released a set of guiding principles to help the building industry adopt resilient design and policies. Since the initial signing, the coalition has added 19 new signatories.
Architects | May 11, 2016
AIA to create a resilience curriculum for architects
The program will teach resilient design and decision-making on hazard mitigation, climate adaptation and community resilience.
Legislation | May 11, 2016
Two bills seek to expand flood insurance policy writing to private carriers
Thanks to new floodplain maps, this market, previously the sole province of a federal program, looks more profitable.
Resiliency | May 2, 2016
Connecticut to develop new code standards for resiliency
Expected more frequent severe weather events due to climate change prompts review.
Resiliency | Apr 6, 2016
Houston at high risk for major damage from hurricanes
After a decade of study, little has been done to improve resiliency.
Resiliency | Mar 24, 2016
HGA and Perkins+Will join National Resilience Initiative Network
The Minneapolis offices of the two firms will partner with the University of Minnesota College of Design in the Upper Midwest hub of the NRI network.
